The Blue Jays having been cheating? That’s great news. It means that Rogers is finally committed to winning. Stealing signs in other forms of cheating are ingrained in baseball. Base runners have been known to try to pick up signs and communicate them to hitters. Catchers will come to the mound and cover their face with their glove for fear of having an opponent read their lips.
Baseball barely had codified rules before players started figuring out ways to bend them. The original Cincinnati Red Stockings during their undefeated 1869 season took advantage of the fact that the infield fly rule hadn’t been invented, turning double plays on deliberately dropped infield pop-ups with runners on base.
Cutting the bases and impeding base runners were among the favorite tricks of the Baltimore Orioles. There was only one umpire per game in the 1890s, and he couldn’t keep an eye on the runners, the fielders and the ball all at once. Hence, if the ump turned his back, a runner would say, bypass third base on his way from second to home. On the other side of the ball, the Orioles were notorious for giving opposing base runners the hip or grab the runner, making the journey around the bases somewhat perilous.
Faking catches, although still practiced, had its heyday in the pre-lighting era. Nowadays any outfielder who traps a ball, either on the ground or against the fence, will hold up his glove to “show” he’s caught it. In the old days, when games were often played in twilight, fielders would sometimes try to really put on a show including pretending to catch a ball that had gone over the fence for a home run.
Then there is the doctoring of the field. Milwaukee Brewers used to move the right field wall, depending on whether the Brewers or the opponents’ had more left-handed power. They at first pulled this little stunt between games, but then decided to do it between innings, in other words, the fence would be rolled out when the opposing team was at bat, and rolled back when the Brewers were up.
The most common, and most famous, means of cheating became just that after baseball banned trick deliveries and foreign substances on the ball after the 1920 season. So common, in fact, that there’s just no point in even trying to list all of the accused spitball, scuffball, greaseball and the like artists who have practiced their craft since that time. It’s worth noting that Gaylord Perry, Don Drysdale, Don Sutton, Dizzy Dean and Whitey Ford are all in the Hall of Fame and all were suspected cheaters. Joe Niekro was suspended in 1985 when an ump found a nail file in his pocket.
Prior to 1940, the rules just said a bat had to be made out of wood. Now, the rule says they have to be one piece of wood, a rule that Norm Cash, Billy Hatcher, Graig Nettles, Amos Otis, Albert Belle, Wilton Guerrero, and Sammy Sosa, among others, have ran afoul of, usually with either cork or superballs.
Finally, let’s get back to sign stealing, another vaguely illegal act that has been around forever. Now, having a coach or a manager who’s good at stealing signs on the field is OK. But, if you use technology and do it off the field, that’s not considered kosher, at least by the aggrieved parties. So the Blue Jays are alleged to be stealing signs from the outfield bleachers using a man in white who would signal when a breaking pitch was being thrown. Anonymous opposition players claim to have seen his routine. Of course the man in white wasn’t reported to have been using binoculars which mean he had amazing vision. Those seats have to be at least 450 feet from home plate. So maybe their was someone else feeding him the signs. Still it would be difficult for a hitter standing in the box to focus on some guy 450 feet away as he readies himself for the next 93 mph fastball coming his way. I like the creativeness and diligence of bloggers who searched the Internet for photos of fans in white sitting in the centre field bleachers at the Rogers Centre.
Baseball history has shown that an act isn’t cheating unless there is an actual rule against it. And then you have to get caught. Wonder if the man in white will ever be found?
